DISQUS

DISQUS Hello! quaintly is using DISQUS, a powerful comment system, to manage its comments. Learn more.

Community Page

Jump to original thread »
Author

The Malaysian Dreamgirl Top 3 (updated!)

Started by pinkpau · 9 months ago

No excerpt available. Jump to website »

80 comments

  • hehe yea I agree with ur top 3! because they've got the fan base, esp. Ringo! but I like Hanis, not so much Cindy but she's ok i guess...

    thanks for posting!

    Megan.... a malaysian from way down south in New Zealand!
  • I agree with your prediction.

    But what about your opinion on who *deserves* to be there?
    (including those eliminated earlier. and not including)

    or more accurately -- who DO NOT deserve to be there?
    *cough cough* so obvious
  • I also believe that the top 3 will be Hanis, Cindy and Ringo. Hanis because she deserves it and is the public's favourite, Cindy because her dad is rich, and Ringo because she has a bunch of diehard blogfans. I am so angry at Ringo for lying about not knowing where her support comes from as it is obvious that she knows it perfectly well. Her performance has been very mediocre. She chose to update her blog instead of calling her mom who is supposedly the only one supporting her. So obviously she knows that the only reason she's still there is because of her blog fans. I take her lie to be a personal insult to my intelligence and everyone else's. What do you feel about it?

    However, on who really deserves to be in the top 3, I think it should be Hanis, Jay and Eyna.
  • Oh, but if I have to chose the top 3 from the current top 6... I can't decide between Adeline and Nadia, but my top 2 are definitely Hanis and Jay.
  • I definitely don't think Ringo deserves to be there. She's so forgettable. She didn't stand out at the ESCADA Challenge AT ALL. Made me wonder whether she actually played the lead role. She was already camouflaged in her black outfit and height, she of all people should've made more effort.
  • my top 3: hanis, jay and nadia.
    but i think ringo's blog fanbase would have win over nadia or jay. sighhhh. she's cute but i don't think she deserves this title
  • Re Malaysian Dreamgirl. A couple of comments made today in the 14th April 2008 entry of Ringo's blog (www.cheeserland.com) may NOT be authentic.
    Friends & fans of Ringo should contact her home telephone number & clarify the matter with her mother.
  • I can't disagree any more with Caryn. Ringo has never been someone who stood out from the rest throughout the whole competition. I may sound a tad judgemental here, but to be a well-acclaimed model, height will always be one of the main criteria, besides having a great personality and physical attributions. Clearly, Ringo lacks one of them, which is the height.

    As for Cindy, suffice to say that I have never favoured her ever since the competition has yet to kick-off. I could roughly tell her personalities from her blog (which you linked her before this) and that was the only time I went there. After a few weeks, she is just exactly like how she is potrayed there.

    Just my two cents woth of thoughts.


    And ohh yea, here's my prediction for the finals.

    The top three who I think rightly deserved their place:
    1. Nadia
    2. Jay
    3. Hanis

    Unfortunately, who can't deny the fact that Malaysians tend to make "genius" choice when it comes to reality shows, and here's the three that I think will get to the final:
    1. Cindy
    2. Ringo
    3. Adeline/Nadia/Hanis (but I guess Nadia will just nick-it)
  • I typed a long ass comment but it just dissapeared T__T

    Anyway, girls that I think will be in the top 3 are Ringo, Cindy and Hanis. Ringo cos of her 'loyal fans', cindy cos she's nvr been in the bottom 3 these past few weeks and Hanis cos everyone loves her (including me).

    Top 3 who deserves to be in the competition are Hanis, Jay and Nadia.
  • Deserving Top 3 (in the ideal world):
    Hanis
    Jay
    Nadia (downfall: bad attitude)/Adeline (downfall: shined a bit too late.. but kudos to her for continue trying and eventually winning the escada challenge)

    Top 3 (in the real world):
    Ringo
    Cindy
    Hanis

    Most undeserving (to reach this far and to be even in the competition right from the beginning): Ringo

    4 major faux pas:
    faux pas #1: lying to elaine daly about the lack of saddest moment
    ~ her way of responding to that question is probably the worst, if not the dumbest approach especially since the question was posed to test her character. plus, she's in a position to win favor from judges, not vice versa. no wonder elaine daly looked pissed.

    faux pas #2: dissing the judges and some of the top 12 contestants, then returned to the show upon recall
    ~ showcase her greed for glamor and glory and cash/prizes and hypocrisy. nobody was holding a gun to force her return - plus, why would one ever wish to go back to a place where u find the quality of judgment questionable or even deplorable?

    faux pas #3: faking her surprise about never being in bottom 3 in front of national viewers and implied that her support came from her mom, her only relative and the general public, thereby hinting upon her (non-existent) liability
    ~ her biggest mistake to date. and her words insulted my intelligence straight-off. does she even thought once of the repercussions of what she utter, or rather, fib?

    faux pas #4: revelation from her mom that she's only in mdg for the car, not to chase after modeling fame or to achieve any modeling aspiration
    ~ this comment from mom had basically placed the final nail to ringo's coffin for ever deserving the title. sorry aunty, as my mom does teach me manners and with all due respect for elders, i dont think voting for your daughter to win a car from a model-search competition is justified. Not only does it defeat the mission of mdg and create unfairness to fellow contestants, it also deprives other more deserving girls of using mdg as a springing board to make a name of themselves in the modeling field.

    even without any of the faux pas, IMHO, Ringo does not have the attributes (height, looks, versatility etc.) to make it as a model.

    On Cindy, she's another story altogether, she's where she's right now thanks to her dad and family.
  • ENYA :(
  • what you said simply coz they have a large fanbase

    if its really 3 of them, i hope hanis wins la.

    voting blindly blind loyalty bleh
  • i really really really do hope Hanis become the first mdg girl, because she's a genuine public favorite and also does have both the attractive personality and qualities to become successful in modeling (she's so tall and slim and did a great catwalk at MIFA!!), as seen from her performance and vast improvements throughout mdg.

    and clearly, the other 2 girls in my top3 list (in the real world) havent produce any outstanding performance to-date at the dreamhouse.
  • I read Ringo's blog quite often. Have nothing against her, I think she's cute. But thats just it. You cannot be "cute" to be a top model. Plus, in the Escada ad, she was totally obscured by all the rest. And I gotta agree with Caryn about her feigning knowledge as to where her votes come from.

    Those whom I THINK will be the top 3:
    -Ringo
    -Cindy
    -Hanis

    Those whom I think DESERVES to be top 3:
    -Jay
    -Hanis
    -Nadia

    I think Jay totally rocks. She totally dominated the whole MIFA catwalk as compared to the rest. I hope you make it Jay.
  • I'm sick and tired of MDG... i just want it to come to and end real soonm cause i want to stop watching with a closure, though i don't expect to like the closure.

    so tired to keep complaining about the little hypocrite girl...
    so i will give comment about what is written by commenter #7 above...

    that girl... is kind of psycho....
  • Which girls will be the top 3?

    Hanis, Ringo and Cindy.

    Which girls SHOULD be the top 3?

    Fiqa, Jay and Hanis.

    At least one of of the three deserves it.
  • i really don't know why is ringo in the competition in the first place. i never liked her from the start. even her blog did not attract my attention. the other girls in mdg improved in terms of their photoshoots n the way they carry themselves but i dont see anything coming from ringo. voters please vote wisely. this is not a best blogger search competition. its a model search competition. you really think ringo has what it takes to be a model? THINK AGAIN. her bunny teeth definitely isn't attractive/sexy.

    the ones i think deserves to be in the top3 are :
    adeline, nadia and cindy.

    i honestly dont know what jay's fans see in her as well.
  • and one more thing to add, it was really annoying how ringo said in one of the episodes somewhere along the lines - "i'm really grateful that i was never in the bottom 3, and i'm actually quite surprised because i only have my mum as my family to vote for me, unlike the others who has their uncle aunty, makcik pakcik, yi ma ku che and all voting for them"

    tell me that didn't irritate you enough to stop voting for her.
    i can't understand how some of you can still say you're ringo's supporter!!!!!! for god's sake, wake up people!
  • Ringo said those sickening lines with such a straight face. Trying to earn pity votes and pretend that she got so far on the public's admiration of her modelling skills instead of just support from her blog fans. No conscience whatsoever. Disgusting. She might do better in a acting contest rather than a modelling one.
  • my vote goes for
    Jay, Nadia and Hanis.

    but the real top 3 will probably be
    Hanis, Ringo and Cindy

    But with Fiqa out already, the show is pretty much meaningless :( Bring Fiqa back!
  • omg and Caryn: spot-on, probably the best faking act ever, and to think that she did it without blinking an eye.

    she's no conscience, no guilt and no sense of appreciation. just an internet addict who complained being "depressed and deprived" in a house filled with 6 other girls while gearing with the thought of winning a car. how she can still feel good abt herself while depriving other girls a shot at the modeling arena through mdg, i could never understand.

    without her, ppl like eyna and fiqa would still be in the run for the title. a big sigh for them.
  • everyone's opinions are quite unanimous with who's deserving and what not. and i agree with what's said above too.

    1. i really think talent's abundance with jay and nadia, although consistency is not something which follows them, sadly.
    2. as for hanis i think she's improving with her photoshoot although i must say her cat walk is waywayway better than the photos she take.
    3. adeline ada talent but expression kosong. tis sad...
    4. cindy's facial features are not up par with what a model should have. she doesn't stand out at all.
    5. ringo's not versatile.

    likability factor plays an important part, but only vote for those we like and are talented is the way to go!! let's also vote for the deserving ppl, and not vote blindly :)

    Jay all the way!!
  • By popularity, my prediction is the same as you. Unless Adeline suddenly get fans after her win in the Escada challenge.
  • Are you attending the student's summit?
  • The comment made by Ringo's mom yesterday in her (Ringo's blog) is probably 99.9 percent FALSE. It looks like someone was up to mischief to sabotage Ringo's chances.
  • i cannot freaking believe it! ringo is voted out O.O
  • haha i watched d but i won't reveal.. but suffice to say, I want Hanis to win!!! (haha yah i changed my mind already su ann!)

    okay time to vote LOL but I REALLY hope the finale is not TOTALLY vote-based. Else, haih.... also can guess who will win la! (read: ugly pink car HAHAHAHAHHA)

    okay so my comment was quite revealing also i think. ohhhhhh well!
  • 'cause all this while i thought she had pretty strong fan base!
  • who should be
    FIQA, hanis & Jay

    who might be
    hanis, cindy & ringo
  • oh my! ringo is out.
  • hehe
  • i think adeline deserved the top 3 chance. but hanis is my choice!

    go Hanis!
  • haha ... i think adeline stands a great chance. She's just one of those naturally occuring camera facies ... how can u possibly have a blooper pic with a face or a body like that???
  • I can't wait for the results!!! :P
    My favourites!!!
    1) Hanis the manis
    2) Jay
    3) Adeline

    But ringo and cindy have strong supporters. :(
  • huh? I don't get it,... i saw the last episode already...

    final 3 is hanis, cindy and adeline. :)
  • I think Fiqa's good.. Jay is as good also.

    I totally agree with faux pas in comment no. 10 - Most undeserving (to reach this far and to be even in the competition right from the beginning): Ringo

    If she wins, it's only becos of her strong fanbase.. not bcos she has the quality of a model. This is my opinion.
  • sigh, my top 3 would be jay, hanis and nadia.

    the real world's top 3, was neither of them save one. bah.
  • cindy blocked her blog already =(
  • *gasps*
    HANIS HANIS
    I'm sure gonna vote for her.
    personality *checked*
    poses *checked*
    catwalk *checked*

    Oh my god, I was totally shocked that Ringo was going to lose..
    but I guess Adeline did show great performance at the end, so I think she's deserving.

    About Cindy, yea I think she is more likable now, I don't know why. But her catwalk isn't good, her poses isn't as strong as Hanis..
  • No, this post isn't gone
  • which host! no wonder sometimes can see ur post sometimes kenot! was this post made in the new host or old?
  • I don't think Ringo did that out of modesty. Everyone knows her fans are supporting her, so she should just admit it and thank them outright. She did it such a roundabout way so she could get away with not mentioning her fans, and still make them feel like she thanked them. Furthermore, she was shown plotting to get more votes from her fans by offering tickets to the finale. Thank goodness she's out. Her face was so shocked.

    Cindy still managed to get into the top 3, of course. But hopefully everyone will be voting for Hanis now instead of having their votes divided between Jay and whoever else, so that should help Hanis win. It was surprising that Adeline managed to get into the top 3 instead of Jay, but Adeline has been showing a lot of improvement throughout the episodes. Jay and Nadia should still be able to do well under Andrew's Models. I'm just glad Ringo's out.

    Go Hanis!
  • i think at this point, the competition has almost come to an end in a somewhat justified manner, regardless of the controversial voting system and how some ppl have 'abused' it:

    1) JAY and NADIA (both of who have potentials to make it as models):
    even though they didnt end up in top3, which is where they deserved to be, and thus lost their chance of securing a 1 yr-modeling-management contract, they had the privilege of visiting andrewsmodel and putting their names into the industry thanks to winning the kenny challenge. however, i think nadia needs to consider toning down her attitude and temper, especially if she's just starting out and a little humility and patience wont hurt. anyway, although they were eliminated from top3, they did not LOSE in the intrinsic sense

    2) ADELINE (the girl who made the late comeback):
    another lucky gal who has the privilege of visiting andrewsmodel. slow starter and way too quiet. but at least she finally started to come out of her shell and shined at the escada challenge and was promptly rewarded. i think she still have to continue improve on her facial expression for photoshoots and her own speech and shyness, but at least we managed to se her forte in one of the many aspects of modeling - commercial shooting. she definitely has the IT girl factor going on :). and i suspect why she is in the top3 is because of her many silent voters ie those that never make noises on the internet. Wont be surprised if they are mostly chinese-educated girls and guys who's into HK cantonese movies and the likes because i think adeline's look does appeals to a crowd like that :)

    3) HANIS (the girl who made the biggest improvement and transformation compared to how she was at the beginning of mdg):
    in her usual safe spot, and best of all, she deserves it based on very transparent reasons. she was disqualified back in kenny challenge and thus lost her opportunity to visit andrewsmodel, but andrew still make a special note of her!!! :)

    4) CINDY (robotic and zoom-like catwalk):
    she was portrayed as a nuisance among the girls in one of the long-ago episodes, but i have to give her credit for eventually toning down some of her dramatic acts and emotions in the episodes of late. i think she still has lots to work and train on in the aspects of runway, photoshoots and the likes, but one thing i have no doubt about her is her performance in modeling stints that involves some acting (eg. commercial modeling) and public speaking (eg. radio commercials - which is why i wasnt the least surprised when she won the red.fm challenge). this girl is a born drama-queen at heart and on stage, so she's suited for this kind of role. and yeah, she's probably still in the show because of her daddy's/families votes, while there are other more deserving girls with the overall modeling package who have been eliminated eg. jay, nadia, fiqa, eyna.

    5) RINGO (height liability and zero modeling factor):
    height is almost the first pre-requisite to make a break in modeling, so compared to all the other girls above, that's her first-and-foremost liability, a permanent one to boot. this mdg show has also exposed a whole different persona of her (which all of us are aware of what it refers to by now) versus how she appears to be behind a computer screen. and yes, everybody knows that the only reason she even reach top6 is due to her blog fan base. on a merit level, she doesnt deserve to go this far and should be out before ppl like eyna and fiqa are. i honestly dont think she has anything going at all for her in any aspects of modeling: all her photoshoots are mediocre and lack versatility, she cant catwalk, she was effortlessly overshadowed and disappeared into oblivion in commercial challenge like escada, she tends to keep to herself and cant communicate or do not know how to sell herself well and in an appropriate way to the audience out there. she's better off doing things she used to do: blogging.

    overall, i am satisfied with the current top 3. not all of them are the most deserving ones, but at least at present, each of them has shown what they are good at: ADELINE (commercial), HANIS (many things :) ), CINDY (any modeling thing that has acting and drama component lol). it could be worst, and i am definitely glad RINGO is finally eliminated.

    however, based on the full package - both personality and modeling potential, HANIS should win the mdg title

    so GO HANIS!
  • hey suann a.k.a pinkpau..

    do you know which part of 1U will the finale be held? and also if we actually need tickets to watch?

    and and if we need tickets right, do you know where can i actually get them??

    thanks!! :)
  • Jay got voted out.I've lost hope in the world!
  • i donno. but the girls look kinda fugly in the fotoshoots
  • Votes externally audited? How to determine who the voters are?? Did the MDG team also vote to keep in those they like???
  • so sad that jay is out cos she really does deserve to be in the top 3. i've never liked cindy since the beginning because of her attitude but i do agree that has been toned down recently but i still think jay deserves it more than cindy. cindy is still in because of her family like what the rest mentioned. it's so unfair that money can buy votes (thru sms as well)

    ringo doesn't have wat it takes to be a model and yea finally she's out. woohoo?

    hanis should be the winner, i hope.
  • @mg:
    well, money will always have the last laugh.
    it is obvious that money politics are practised in this competition as well. you hope hanis will win, but we all know that cindy is going to win it anyway.

    perhaps the people who has been voting jay and nadia all this while will team-up and vote for hanis? ^^
  • hahahha oooooh the phone calls in p4.

    i'm so sorry but i couldn't help literally LOL-ing the moment someone said this...

    "transluCENT", pronounced as "trans-lu-Cent", with a hard C, like for "Cat" LOL. translucent. hahaha.
  • cindy is a bloody fake b**** la....
    pls.... imagine if she wins...she'll be the 'epitome' of malaysian dreamgirls? is that what we want people to think? that all malaysian girls are like her? *puke!*

    *translukent?* *youuuu kneeoooww?*

    vote for hanis pls....

    and in p4, she was literally backstabbing adeline (who not only spoke up for her during earlier interviews, but chose not to take sides during the 'war') during the conversation between cindy, ringo, hanis and nadia....

    HYPOCRITE TO THE MAX!
  • eh i was there at 1u today and they had runways all set up... might be for the malaysian dreamgirl finale as well.. so you might get your wish! xD
  • didnt read this entry till i watched the latest episode - am not a big fan of spoilers (who is?)

    when hanis and jay got called out - that was such a painful moment! they are, i feel, are deserving to be in the finale. but alas...

    seriously, between hanis, cindy and adeline - it's a no-brainer. BUT since it all boils down to votes, i sure hope hanis emerges as the first mdg.

    so folks in malaysia - vote for hanis!!!
  • to carol: i burst out laughing when i heard the "translu(k)ent" word.
  • I still think they can do better in the pictures, while these are some of the better ones, they still lack soul and eyes look dead. I guess mainly due to the artistic direction requiring the girls to look "spaced out" .. -_-
  • I'm all in for HANIS~ I also want Eyna, Fiqa and Jay back!!!
  • booooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
    MDG is a major disappointment.

    Me want Fiqa! and Nadia! and Jay!

    Let me just emo now. :(
  • woops I broke the frames. Sorry SuAnn! :P
  • WTH... Cindy still in arh? stupid...
  • Dont u think that Cindy looks a bit old in her pic? Really lah..... :Like a lau-ah-mu like that.. Not entirely Cindy's fault tho. Cos her hairstyle.. man.. really old la..
  • hehe, i think cindy's dad sounded like eric tsang
  • i just absolutely loved the way Hanis handled Cindy in the footage of the last 2mins of Ep15 part 4. hahaha!

    Cindy attacked her for saying what she thinks, but Hanis just gave her this "whatever" look and laughed it off -- ("Ok lah, if Cindy wants to think that way I cannot stop her." *exasperated laugh*)

    and OMGzzzz, Cindy is like totally backstabbing "someone." Could it be Adeline? hehe

    So mysterious though, that after Ringo's phonecall (dunno with who that was) where she learned that Cindy's blog gets 2000 visits a day, that the blog has suddenly become private.

    Events leading to the finale make it sooo exciting! XD
  • Cindy's picture is not nice la! She looked like a tranquilized pufferfish. bah. Hanis' picture is SO GORGEOUSSSS!! I think even Tyra Banks will approve wtf.

    Hanis for the gold!! I am going to steal my mom and dad's handphones now to vote, HAHAHHAH.
  • Everybody Knows
    by Leonard Cohen

    Everybody knows that the dice are loaded
    Everybody rolls with their fingers crossed
    Everybody knows that the war is over
    Everybody knows the good guys lost
    Everybody knows the fight was fixed
    The poor stay poor, the rich get rich
    That's how it goes
    Everybody knows


    Everybody knows that the boat is leaking
    Everybody knows that the captain lied
    Everybody got this broken feeling
    Like their father or their dog just died .....
  • I like hanis too!

    used to like nadia and jay, but then their latest pictures like tak cantik already

    dont like cindy and adeline

    =(
  • #

    did u guys notice wat ringo talked about on the phone? In episode 15 part 4, she said she’s worry bcoz she no longer updates her blog, n scare to lose votes from her fans. She ask d guy on d line how many ardent n loyal fans she has who keep voting 4 her. The guy keep track of d number.. ‘about 50′, he said.

    wat i tink is dat prior to going into the dreamhouse, she asked her fren (or possible bf), d guy on d phone, (possibly Mr. BBQ or TT) to update her blog frequently with self-promoting posts of hers n continue remind fans 2 vote 4 her n possible attract readers who read her blog out of curiosity to vote for her too. And d guy deleted her all negative comments or non-praising neutral comments on her blog lest her fans would agree with d comments n stop voting 4 her, also for new readers 2 read comments dat she’s good, she’s nice, she’s pretty, she did well bla bla bla…

    She did have a strategy to gather votes…

    Possibly MDG production team find out bout dis, insist her to delete d previous self-promoting post of her n probably even stop her from updating new post. thus, d revomal of previous post by Mr. BBQ and some crap dat Mr. BBQ cant guest blog anymore, replaced by TT who apparently blog nonsense…

    n listen to d phone conversation of Cindy, she mentioned dat there’s some changes in d rules in d company, possibly bout voting rules..

    i tink ringo was out probably not bcoz she got lesser votes than d top 3 girls, but d production team kicked her out…
  • i dunno lah. cindy just looks.... stiff. like she's just standing there. seems a bit like she didnt put in much effort. hanis looks good! adeline..... she's okay, except her face! like you said, su ann, she has that "duh" blur look on her face ALL THE TIME. it irritates me. hahaha I hope Hanis will win! :D I sort of hoped nadia and jay would be in the top 3 though :(
  • I think one of the reason Ringo's reader stopped voting is because the abruptly stopped posting by Mr. BBQ which was bringing in more supporter and readers. Also, the mundane and quite rude post by TT angered most readers.
  • VOTE FOR HANIS!!!! CINDY IS lame! Cant stand her! *yuck* What kind of role model will she be if she won? omfg.
  • cindy said translukent wtf.
  • I felt tired watching all the drama's in MDG at the end of the day ... -____________-"
    Don't enjoy it at all..it's not even 20% of ANTM.
    But still, my fav girl in MDG would be Hanis. Hope she wins. hehe.
  • i love hanis too! hope she wins!!
    i dont want cindy to win...she cant model for nuts, she cant do catwalk, her photos are one kind.
    but hor... i dont understand 1 thing. how come sazzy kept calling 'hanis' as datin???
  • Cindy should just die.. Such a whiny rich brat.
  • i remember that translukent episode!!! was laughing my ass off. cannot stand her!
  • Is there a dress code for the Malaysian Dream Girls finale @ 1 utama?
  • Money bought success...Cindy's dad bought her the MDG title!
  • Cindy won?! sorry i sumhow havent read or heard anything...can someone explain!!! Hanis should have won this! there is obviously no certainty in the system, i think judges should have juged until the last few leaving it to us to judge. please dont tell me Cindy won!
  • i think we should vote her out! we should express our unhapiness to MDG! she is not a dream girl to any of us! shes a joke!
  • haha... did you see alison's reaction to cindy in episode 18.1?
    so hilarious, her "what-the-hell-is-she-talking-about?" look?
  • Hey Su Ann! Thanks for having me in your blog. And thank you for believing in me *honoured*. To my supporters, YOU GUYS ROCK GILA!

Add New Comment

Returning? Login